Overview
Mackie Properties, LLC operates from 1800 W 17th St in Bloomington, Indiana, serving as a property management company, apartment rental agency, commercial real estate agency, homeowners' association, and real estate agency. The firm’s directory-assigned property types are commercial and apartment, though its broad category list suggests it may also handle residential rentals. Bloomington is home to 53 listed property management firms, and Mackie Properties ranks #8 by public review volume in the city, indicating a relatively high level of customer engagement compared with local peers.
Services and specialties
Mackie Properties is listed under five categories: property management, apartment rental agency, commercial real estate agency, homeowners' association, and real estate agency. That combination points to a firm equipped to manage apartment communities and commercial properties, and likely to assist with HOA administration and brokerage services. The directory assigns it commercial and apartment property types, so owners of retail, office, or multifamily assets are the most direct fit. Renters searching for apartments in Bloomington may also find the firm’s rental agency listing relevant. The firm’s address on West 17th Street places it near the city’s west side, with convenient access to downtown Bloomington and nearby communities such as Ellettsville, Smithville-Sanders, and Nashville.
What the public rating suggests
A 4.1 out of 5 rating from 88 public reviews is a moderate sample—large enough to be meaningful but not so large that it eliminates the possibility of outlier experiences. The score sits above Bloomington’s average rated firm rating of 3.3 and slightly above Indiana’s average of 3.9. That gap suggests Mackie Properties generally satisfies more of its reviewers than the typical Bloomington firm, but prospective clients should read recent reviews for patterns rather than relying on the aggregate alone. Because the review count is 88, it is not a small sample, but it is still worth checking whether complaints cluster around specific service areas such as maintenance or communication.
Who it may suit
Owners of apartment buildings or commercial properties in Bloomington are the most obvious audience, given the firm’s listed specialties. HOA boards seeking management or administrative support may also find the homeowners' association category relevant. Renters looking for apartments through a local agency could use the firm’s apartment rental listing. Investors comparing managers in a market where only 10 firms are listed as apartment-focused and just 1 as commercial-focused may see Mackie Properties as one of the few local options covering both. It may also suit clients who value a firm with a relatively high review volume in the Bloomington market.
Questions to ask before hiring
Prospective clients should ask which property types the firm manages most frequently and whether it handles both apartment and commercial assets under the same team. Ask for a clear explanation of fees, the scope of HOA services if relevant, and how maintenance requests are tracked. Renters should confirm application requirements and lease terms directly. Owners should request references from properties similar in size and type to their own, and ask how the firm communicates during emergencies. Because the public rating is based on 88 reviews, ask how the firm responds to negative feedback and what has changed as a result.
How it compares locally
Bloomington’s 53 listed firms have an average rating of 3.3, while Mackie Properties holds a 4.1. Statewide, the average rated firm in Indiana scores 3.9, so Mackie Properties is slightly above that benchmark as well. Its #8 rank by review volume in Bloomington places it among the more reviewed local firms, which can be a useful signal of market presence. The local property-type mix is heavily residential (42 firms), with only 10 apartment-focused and 1 commercial-focused firm, so Mackie’s combined apartment and commercial listing is relatively distinctive in this market.
Verdict
Mackie Properties, LLC is a established Bloomington firm with a solid public rating and a broad category footprint that includes apartment, commercial, HOA, and rental agency services. It appears best suited to apartment and commercial property owners, HOA boards, and renters seeking a local agency. The 4.1 rating from 88 reviews is a reasonable starting point, but clients should verify service scope and terms directly before signing.
How to read this profile. This is editorial content compiled from public business listing data and directory records. It is not a customer review, a rating of service quality, or an endorsement. Fees, licensing, service scope and terms change; confirm them directly with the firm before signing anything.