5 property management companies in Columbia City, Indiana. Compare services, ratings, phone numbers and websites.
Columbia City has 5 property management companies listed in this directory, with 3 publishing a website and 4 carrying a public rating. The average rating among rated firms is 4.8. Urban Sands Realty and Property Management has the highest public review volume in the city, with 223 reviews.
The most common specialty here is residential, with 4 firms. Property owners should compare firms that actually manage their property type rather than choosing the first listing. Use the filters above to narrow by specialty, website availability and minimum rating, then open two or three firm pages and compare fees, reporting and maintenance policies.
Updated 2026. Listing data comes from public business profiles and may change; confirm fees, licensing and availability directly with each firm.
Showing 1 of 5 firms
Columbia City, IN 46725
www.coldwellhomes.com/office/CBREG12/289-west-walker-way-suite-2-columbia-city-in-46725
289 W Walker Way #2, Columbia City, IN 46725
This directory lists 5 property management companies in Columbia City, Indiana. 3 of them publish a website, and 4 have a public rating. Coverage includes residential, HOA, commercial, apartment and short-term rental managers where those specialties exist locally.
Most residential managers in the US charge roughly 8–12% of collected rent, often plus a leasing fee of 50–100% of one month's rent and a renewal fee. Columbia City pricing varies by property type, condition and scope. Ask each firm for a written fee schedule, including maintenance markups and termination terms, because the headline percentage is only part of the total cost.
Shortlist three firms that manage your property type, then ask the same questions about fees, maintenance approvals, owner reporting, after-hours coverage, licensing and termination. Read recent reviews for repeated complaints, ask for a sample owner statement, and compare the all-in cost for a typical 12-month tenancy rather than the monthly percentage alone.